Prime Minister Mark Carney stated this week that Jewish Canadians are facing significant targeting, while announcing a new anti-racism council that includes two members whose views on Israel have raised concerns. Critics have expressed dissatisfaction with the council's composition, questioning how it can effectively combat antisemitism with members perceived as unsupportive of Jewish community concerns.
Omar Alghabra, a former cabinet minister and Member of Parliament, has faced backlash for his past comments regarding Israel and his response to the October 7 Hamas attacks. Critics, including opposition leader Pierre Poilievre, have highlighted Alghabra's previous lobbying efforts to keep Hezbollah legal, raising doubts about his suitability for the council. However, reports indicate that Alghabra has condemned Hamas as a terrorist organization in the past.
The second controversial member, Avnish Nanda, has been involved in efforts to maintain a pro-Palestinian encampment at the University of Alberta, which some argue has created a hostile environment for Jewish students following the recent attacks.
In April, B’nai Brith Canada reported a record 6,800 antisemitic incidents in 2025, a 9.4% increase from the previous year. Rabbi Zolly Claman expressed shock at Alghabra's appointment, questioning its constructive nature for the Jewish community.
During the announcement of the Council on Rights, Equality and Inclusion, Carney emphasized the need for a targeted response to the crisis of antisemitism in Canada. B'nai Brith Canada acknowledged Carney's recognition of the issue but expressed concern over the council's authority and effectiveness in addressing the crisis. The organization called for the establishment of a National Emergency Task Force on Antisemitism to provide immediate action.
Activist Ariella Kimmel criticized the council's approach, stating that the Jewish community, while only 1.2% of Canada's population, is the target of 75% of hate crimes. Kimmel argued that the government needs to address specific antisemitic sentiments rather than creating another broad council on racism. Fox News Digital reached out to Carney’s office and the council members for comments.
