Hawaii Supreme Court Justice Todd Eddins issued a 91-page majority opinion on July 18, 2026, in the case of State v. Granillo, which overturned a 1990 conviction for kidnapping and sexual assault. Eddins criticized the U.S. Supreme Court, led by Chief Justice John Roberts, for weakening constitutional rights and advancing a political agenda. He argued that Hawaii's Constitution offers stronger protections than those currently interpreted by the U.S. Supreme Court and expressed concern that the Court has abandoned key civil rights principles established in landmark cases such as Brown v. Board of Education. Eddins stated that the Roberts Court's approach reflects outdated interpretations from cases like Dred Scott v. Sandford and Plessy v. Ferguson. He claimed that recent decisions have expanded government power while diminishing individual rights and criticized the Court's interpretation of the Equal Protection Clause as ignoring its original purpose. The opinion has drawn criticism from legal observers for its unusual focus on the U.S. Supreme Court. Eddins has been on the Hawaii Supreme Court since 2020, appointed by former Governor David Ige.
Why this rating? · 5 signals
Signals flagged in the original
- loaded language: 'blasts'
- loaded language: 'disgraceful'
- loaded language: 'shocking'
- vague attribution present
- headline asserts a conclusion / scare-quotes
Provisional estimate — refines shortly Full breakdown ↓
Hawaii Supreme Court Justice Critiques U.S. Supreme Court in Ruling
Justice Todd Eddins of the Hawaii Supreme Court delivered a critical opinion regarding the U.S. Supreme Court while overturning a criminal conviction. He argued that the U.S. Supreme Court has weakened constitutional rights and failed to uphold civil rights principles, suggesting that Hawaii's Constitution provides stronger protections. His opinion has received notable criticism from legal experts.
No note attached
on this article.
Bias Analysis
Bias Indicators Removed
- ✕ loaded language: 'blasts'
- ✕ loaded language: 'disgraceful'
- ✕ loaded language: 'shocking'
- ✕ vague attribution present
- ✕ headline asserts a conclusion / scare-quotes
Original vs. Neutral
Liberal circuit judge blasts SCOTUS conservatives, says Hawaii will defy high court
Hawaii Supreme Court Justice Critiques U.S. Supreme Court in Ruling