Legal Battle Over St. Michael and St. Florian Statues in Quincy Could Reach Supreme Court

A legal dispute regarding the installation of statues of St. Michael the Archangel and St. Florian outside the public safety headquarters in Quincy, Massachusetts, may escalate to the U.S. Supreme Court. The Becket Fund for Religious Liberty is representing the city, stating that a decision from the Massachusetts Supreme Court is expected soon. Joseph Davis, senior counsel at Becket, expressed confidence that the court will reject the ACLU's position, which he described as contrary to artistic expression and historical acknowledgment. The controversy arose after plans to install two 10-foot bronze statues were reported, with critics arguing that the installation violates the Massachusetts Constitution's religious neutrality clause. The legal challenge began in May 2025, led by various faith groups and taxpayers, who claim the statues lack a secular purpose. The ACLU of Massachusetts is among the plaintiffs, while supporters argue that the statues honor first responders and are appreciated by individuals of various faiths. Quincy Mayor Thomas Koch stated that the statues were chosen to inspire and honor first responders. The ACLU maintains that the installation of the statues as the sole adornments on a government building violates state constitutional provisions.