Rep. Mike Carey, a Republican from Ohio, questioned Smithsonian leadership during a Committee on House Administration hearing regarding the National Museum of American History's (NMAH) decision to remove the phrase 'American history' from its mission statement. Carey asked Anthea Hartig, the NMAH administrator, about the reasoning behind this change, which was described as a move to help people move beyond an 'America-first mentality.'
Carey's inquiries reflect ongoing debates among Republican lawmakers about the preservation of American heritage and national identity. Progressive thinkers, including Hartig, argue that acknowledging the darker aspects of American history is essential for understanding the country's past and shaping its future policies.
Republican lawmakers have expressed concerns over narratives that characterize the U.S. as defined by oppression or slavery, contrasting these views with the belief that American ideals, as articulated in foundational documents, should be emphasized.
In a report released during President Donald Trump's administration, the museum's decision to alter its mission statement was criticized, with Hartig being specifically mentioned. Hartig defended her position, stating that the museum does not take sides in political debates and aims to present a comprehensive view of American life. She emphasized that reframing narratives does not equate to erasing history, but rather includes perspectives that were previously overlooked.
Carey concluded his questioning by quoting George Orwell, emphasizing the importance of understanding history in shaping identity, and reiterated his concerns about the removal of 'American history' from the museum's mission.