A federal judge in Oklahoma ruled that a Tulsa County sheriff’s deputy violated a woman’s Fourth Amendment rights by searching Flock Safety license-plate reader data without a warrant, and ordered evidence obtained afterward suppressed.
Judge Sara E. Hill said the deputy had no apparent reason to search the woman’s plate other than that her vehicle had California plates, according to the reports. The deputy used the travel-history data in seeking to search her vehicle, where reports say 91 pounds of methamphetamine were found. Hill described persistent, dragnet-style public surveillance as raising constitutional concerns.
The ruling concerns warrantless searches of automated license-plate-reader data, including Flock’s system. It does not establish binding precedent, according to Hacker News’ summary of 404 Media’s reporting. The Hill reported that the judge said such searches may violate the Fourth Amendment without adequate probable cause.