The Supreme Court heard arguments Monday in a case over Boulder, Colorado’s effort to seek damages from ExxonMobil and Suncor Energy for climate-change-related natural-disaster costs. After roughly two hours of arguments, reports said the court’s likely ruling was unclear.
The dispute concerns whether Boulder may pursue claims under state law or whether federal law, including the Clean Air Act, prevents such suits. Justice Brett Kavanaugh said interstate air and water pollution are matters for federal law, while Justice Elena Kagan said state-by-state cases could conflict with Congress’s approach to greenhouse-gas regulation, according to the Los Angeles Times. The case is an appeal from a Colorado Supreme Court decision that allowed Boulder’s claims to proceed, The Hill reported. Justice Samuel Alito did not participate after recusing himself, Fox News reported.